Shop
   

 Home > Police Stories > The Justice of the Peace

WHAT KIND OF JUSTICE IS THIS?
written by The Justice of the Peace on the 24th August 2017 at 12:59

Before retirement from the bench from time to time I posted on cases where I was in court the participants and all identifying features obscured of course.  Now I am an ordinary member of the public reading of cases countrywide but with, I hope, some knowledge that Joe Public lacks. For example Mr Public is not aware that currently there is no charge of "domestic violence" per se but the usual charge, common assault by beating, is highly aggravated if the offence could be construed as DV. Indeed the offence as such in certain instances can be used to exclude a possible offender from his.....it`s usually a male.....own property on the say so of a police officer without any interference from a court. Another aggravating circumstance which also applies to many crimes from common assault to murder is premeditation.  I`ll add another aggravating factor which paradoxically is sometimes argued as mitigating by ignorant solicitors; drunkenness. To top it all the vulnerability of the victim must also be considered. Now read the report on this case

Both as a retired magistrate and as a member of the public I find the sentence absolutely shocking. Even allowing for a guilty plea it seems the bench did not consider that not only did the combination of offences not reach the custody threshold, they warranted only a minimum community punishment. There will be no official looking into this matter. Nobody on that bench will be admonished. The legal advisor will carry on as previously and every reader of local media and the police officers involved will wonder just what kind of justice is available for scum like this offender. There should be an official complaint so that these J.P.s dispense justice according to society`s requirements even although these requirements are based on a tick box exercise called Sentencing Guidelines. They are all we have.
 Originally posted at http://thejusticeofthepeaceblog.blogspot.com/2017/08/what-kind-of...

Similar Stories

The Shoe on the Other Foot Posted on 04th June 2012
Close Encounters of The Jeremy Kyle Kind Posted on 19th October 2012
Now they face justice & What an abject failure: Posted on 14th August 2011
Durham Constabulary providing support as Malaysian Airlines victim John Alder family issue triubute Posted on 19th July 2014
Family of Matthew Jordan thank people for their support Posted on 16th April 2014